Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bagel with Sliced Nova Lox and Cream Cheese
Chicken Caesar Salad Platter
Chef Salad Platter
Garden Salad Platter
About
Sam I Am Bagels
Welcome to the delightful world of Sam I Am Bagels, a beloved gem nestled in Piscataway, NJ, at 1665 Stelton Rd UNIT #H. Known for their warm atmosphere and mouthwatering offerings, this bagel shop has been winning over locals and visitors alike.
As you step inside, you'll instantly feel the charm of a community-centered eatery. Customers often rave about the exceptional service provided by the owner and his son, who treat every patron like family. It's rare to find such genuine hospitality in today's fast-paced world, making your visit even more memorable.
The star of the show here, of course, is the food. The menu showcases a tantalizing array of bagels and sandwiches that cater to every craving:
- Hot Sandwiches from the Grill: Whether you're in the mood for a classic Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on an everything bagel or a savory Ham and Egg Sandwich, you'll find your taste buds singing with every bite.
- Hot Bagel Sandwiches: For those who prefer a fusion of flavors, try their Hot Pastrami or Corned Beef Ruben Sandwiches, both expertly crafted for a delicious experience.
- Specialty Sandwiches: Explore unique creations like the Tina Turner Sandwich, featuring solid albacore tuna, or the hearty Paul Newman Sandwich, piled high with roast beef and horseradish dressing.
With prices that are friendlier than you might expect, Sam I Am Bagels provides an array of flavors at a value that’s hard to beat. Many customers, like Priyank Trivedi, have echoed the sentiment that this locale is not just about great food but an experience that nurtures community connection.
Freshness is key here. Regulars claim that you will not find bagels as fresh anywhere else, with some even celebrating innovative flavors like the Jalapeno Bagel or the Egg Everything Bagel. There's a delightful surprise with every bite, making each visit a new adventure.
Although the space could use some tender loving care, customers like Kezia still find joy in the delicious bagels and friendly service. The variety offered, including all-time favorites and unique spins, ensures there’s something for everyone—from busy families to hungry workers needing a quick, satisfying bite.
In summary, Sam I Am Bagels is more than just a bagel shop; it’s a cherished institution where flavor, community, and service intersect. Come for the food, stay for the experience—and you’ll surely understand why this spot has captured the hearts (and stomachs) of so many. Give them a try; you won't regret it!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Ive been going here for over 7 years and I can safely say that they are the best bagel shop around. Their food is always amazing and fresh. But besides the food the owner and his son always treat you like a regular. The customer service is unbelievable especially in this day in age. Not only is the food great but the people are great. Where can you get that nowadays? My usual is the bacon,egg,cheese w grilled onions on an everything bagel. I highly recommend Sam I Am to everyone. Give it a try if you havent, you wont be disappointed! ”
“ First time coming here and i love the bagels! The bagels are fresh and the people working there are very nice too. I had a bacon egg and cheese with a cinnamon raisin bagel and it was by far one of the best bagels Ive had. I will come back again for sure! ”
“ Absolutely delicious meals ... bagels eggs bacon pancakes I recommend those Fresh food .... Try !!!! YUMMI ... ”
“ Been a regular for 56 years and there is no better bagel or service in town. Beyond fair prices and excellent customer service. They will go the extra mile to accommodate you. Flavored cream cheeses pack way more than your normal bagel place. Great deals if youre picking up a dozen for work or the kids. More variety than most place with a unique spin on the Jalapeno bagel, egg everything and dozens of fun sandwich combinations. ”
“ I got a surprise bag and they were definitely not kidding when they told me I will be getting over a dozen of fresh bagels! Staff were friendly, great service but the place itself seems like it could use some TLC. So far the bagels that we had were delicious, thanks again! ”
“ God, these sandwiches are so good. Open faced Chicken Salad Melt, Roast Beef on Eye with Sweet Peppers and Mayo and Swiss, Pasatrami and Corned Beef on Eye with Swiss, Saurkraut, and French Dressing...every sandwich Ive had is so good. Looking forward to ordering more. Update Cheese and Pepper Omelet is banging. Better than other places, they just make it like homemade. Update French Toast is also banging. ”
“ Update 62622 Weve ordered here many times by now. We usually order breakfast. The food is great. It tastes like home cooked food and I mean that in the best of ways. The value is incredible. With prices rising everywhere, this restaurant is still friendly on the wallet. The staff is very nice. They have always gotten our orders right. They read the comments in the order as well. ZERO complaints. Thank you for being awesome! ”
“ So I ordered a surprise bag of bagles from the location online. Let me tell you I recieved a large bag stuffed with the freshest bagles I have ever had in my life. When I say fresh I mean they still had the heat on them from coming out of the oven, and many of them were still connected because they were they fresh. Looking forward to sharing the extras with my friends and family. Thank you for an amazing deal on some of the freshest and best quality bagels I have ever had. ”